Those entering residential childcare for the first time are given Child Protection Training to prepare them for receiving disclosures of abuse and supporting a young person through the harrowing process that follows.
Disclosures may not be chronological, factual or timely. Some may use symbolism, such as a young person who spoke in detail of a lamb being abused by sheep. Others may involve naming a current staff member to disclose a past event. In short, the content is right, but the adult named is not.
When examined through an attachment and trauma-informed approach, the motivations behind ‘false’ allegations from young people are complex. We have explored some motivations, and for the sake of brevity the explorations are simplified, however we know there is never a single motivation for any action. When complex trauma is involved, motivations are intertwined and embedded in varying levels of conscious awareness.
Practice Disclosures
A young person is putting immense trust in an adult when they disclose to them; they are trusting that the adult won’t blame them, or punish them, that they will be heard, supported and prioritised. In order to test what kind of adult is currently looking after them they may then use practice disclosures before risking anything else.
Trauma Re-enactment
Trauma re-enactment can involve actions, such as returning to areas where the trauma occurred, or repetitive risk-taking related to the trauma, and it can also involve repeated recounting of the story in different narrative vehicles. Re-enactment is often compulsive and can feel as confusing and contradictory to the individual as to those around them. A young person may be caught in a cycle of telling their story over and over again, with different adults taking on the role of the abuser.
Manifestation of Neuro-divergence
One young person we supported was sexually abused during a kinship care placement. The young person wanted justice, and so sought out the Police. The young person had complex additional needs, and found any kind of verbal communication challenging, let alone that involving such distress. The young person often relies on symbolic description, he told the police that this person reached into his chest and ripped his heart out. The disclosure was not recognised as trauma by the police.
Trauma and the Memory
In short terms, trauma impacts the way in which we store memories both at the time and in future recall. Theorists believe we store each trauma in a separate space, especially those that occur in relationships with caregivers. Outside of that space, it cannot consciously be recalled.
However, trauma leaks out from wherever it is stored, and these leaks can result in young people giving out fragmented and even contradictory fractions of disclosures. As with the other motivations the abuse occurred, the trauma is real, but some of the details are incorrect.
In Residential Care
Countless hours of research have informed our industry’s efforts to encourage young people to tell us when they encounter abuse or harmful practice from the staff paid to take care of them. What happens when a child speaks out and are told that their story not believed and that they will not even be asked to recount it because of their history?
If we want to be attachment and trauma informed, if we want to centre young people at all times, we have to consider their trauma history. When did they first make allegations? What type were they? Against whom? In response to what? Were they retracted? Do they mirror known or suspected earlier traumas? Does the new allegation sit apart from those before? Have there been concerns from others about the individual accused? We ask ourselves as many questions as possible; an allegation is the start of the conversation, not the reason a child is silenced.
There are many reasons why an adult may not hear a child when they disclose abuse but none of those reasons make any difference to the child asking for our help. However, for the sake of illustration, some of the reasons for failing to protect a child include not actively listening, wilful disbelief, fear of the impact, fear of accusing another adult, or projecting adult motives onto the child’s actions such as believing them to be vengeful or disordered in some way.
It is our belief, that the young people in our care who have made ‘false’ allegations are those that have suffered traumas, many of which occurred in relationships with adult caregivers.
Framing a child as having a history of ’false’ allegations is as reductive as it is harmful. All behaviour is communication, and all communication is an opportunity for the adult to lessen some of the child’s distress. A history of ‘false’ allegations does not preclude a child from experiencing present abuse. We know predatory adults seek out children who have experienced abuse because the predators understand that the child is less likely to be heard and believed.
At the very least, let us allow every child the opportunity to speak.
Article by a Therapeutic Services Co-ordinator, Common Thread